Loading…
Thursday, October 23, 2014
Current Weather
Loading Current Weather....
Published: Sunday, 7/6/2014

COMMENTARY

Times are tough, as usual; America, as usual, perseveres

BY DAVID SHRIBMAN
PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE EXECUTIVE EDITOR
Shribman Shribman
Enlarge

Militants formally have declared a new Islamic state consisting of parts of Syria and Iraq. Russia, loaded with nuclear weapons and resentment, is looking menacingly at Ukraine.

China is rich and restive. Israel is in upheaval over the deaths of three teenagers. There is no reason to believe Iran is refraining from pressing forward with nuclear-weapons research. North Korea is unpredictable. Things are pretty bad.

Let’s backpedal 100 years. Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary has been assassinated, Austria is looking to Germany for support. Before long, Russia and France will have mobilized. Things are really bad.

Maybe we should go back a century and a half. The year 1864 was one of Civil War battles (Wilderness, Spotsylvania, Petersburg, Atlanta, Mobile Bay) and a vital election (Democrats nominated the reluctant warrior, George McClellan). Things are catastrophic.

How about only a half century? Fifty years ago this week, President Lyndon Johnson had just signed the landmark civil-rights bill. But before long, there would be riots in Harlem, three civil-rights workers would be found dead in Mississippi, and Democrats would confront a rebellion at their national convention.

In a month, two U.S. destroyers would be attacked in the Gulf of Tonkin, or so the story would be told, precipitating increased American involvement in Vietnam. Things are bad and getting worse.

Before 1964 would be out, Americans would hear two competing views of their future. One was from Mr. Johnson, en route to a 44-state landslide in the November election.

The other was from Ronald Reagan, an underemployed actor turned activist who would give a celebrated pre-election television speech for Barry Goldwater, who would win less than 39 percent of the presidential vote.

“From Johnson in the East, [Americans] heard prophecies of a coming era that looked like God’s kingdom on Earth, arriving shortly,” Jonathan Darman writes in Landslide, a forthcoming retrospective on 1964. “From Reagan in the West, they’d heard of the potential for calamity and the extinguishing of freedom, coming soon. Both visions could not stand. Here was the beginning of a great drama.”

All of this raises questions we might contemplate on this long holiday weekend, anchored on the anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and its proclamation of American freedom:

How do we measure the peril our nation has faced — in 1776, when it was young and idealistic; in 1812, when it was vulnerable; in 1861, when it was torn asunder; in 1917, when it waded into European affairs for the first time; in 1941, when war came to Pearl Harbor; in 1950 and 1961, when threats rumbled through Southeast Asia; in 1979, when American diplomats were held hostage by the Iranian Revolution, and in 2001, when foreign terrorism crashed into our domestic life?

And what about 1827, 1857, 1877, 1893, 1907, 1920, 1929, 1937, 1973, 1981, and 2008, when economic distress endangered Americans’ well-being?

Is the human story — or the American story — simply a tale of woe, challenge piled upon challenge, danger built upon danger?

On weekends such as this, when we contemplate our national narrative, we sometimes wonder whether we ever have experienced a period without threat of calamity. The first decade of the 20th century? Maybe the 1950s?

That 1950s were a period of unusual conformity (unless you count the green shoots, or more precisely the black shoots, of rock music and the civil-rights movement, or read Jack Kerouac, J.D. Salinger, and Allen Ginsburg).

That decade was a period of peace (unless you count the Korean War and the challenges of the Suez crisis and the Hungarian revolution). It was a period of domestic tranquility (unless you leaned to the left and encountered the McCarthy purges or were black and wanted to attend Little Rock Central High School in Arkansas).

It was a period of prosperity (unless you worried that the economy was warped by the Cold War, stifled by the absence of women in workplaces outside the home, or threatened with inflation).

All the current half-century retrospectives of the decade that followed carry overtures of deep peril. In the 1960 presidential campaign, John Kennedy and Richard Nixon spoke of the decade ahead as a dangerous period of change and challenge. Both men sowed worries about America’s ability to compete with the Soviets and maintain our freedoms.

In the 1984 election, both Mr. Reagan and former vice president Walter Mondale spoke of the hazards of the period.

The sober lesson might be that crises are always with us. There are few periods of serenity. The promise of “domestic tranquility” in the Constitution was a chimera, promised and yearned for, yet illusory, maybe impossible.

But on this holiday weekend, should we take that as a gloomy lesson, or should we be inspired by the nation’s ability to confront crisis? Should we continue to believe in our nation’s founding principles and to work to build a nation worthy of its promise? And especially that original Fourth of July promise: to recognize that all of us were created equal and entitled to a chance for life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness?

Yes, we live in a perilous time. It is more perilous than that of the 1950s perhaps, though a Cold War raged. It is less perilous than that of the 1940s, when a hot war raged.

The survival of our country is less uncertain than it was during the Civil War or World War II. But our liberties are more uncertain than in the 1960s and 1970s.

The hard times are always with us, more or less. But above all, this weekend, and this recitation of all the woes we have confronted, should remind us that our heritage and values require more rather than less from us — and have given us more rather than less.

David Shribman is executive editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Contact him at: dshribman@post-gazette.com.



Guidelines: Please keep your comments smart and civil. Don't attack other readers personally, and keep your language decent. If a comment violates these standards or our privacy statement or visitor's agreement, click the "X" in the upper right corner of the comment box to report abuse. To post comments, you must be a Facebook member. To find out more, please visit the FAQ.

Related stories