Delayed reactions: Late Alzheimer’s diagnoses common, troubling

7/22/2013
BY ANITA CREAMER
SACRAMENTO BEE
David Schooley, 57, center, huddles with his children, Nathaniel, 12, and Hannah, 6, while playing football in his front yard.
David Schooley, 57, center, huddles with his children, Nathaniel, 12, and Hannah, 6, while playing football in his front yard.

SACRAMENTO — Claire Schooley tried for several years to get doctors to diagnose what was going on with her husband, David, now 57.

He would ask her the same questions again and again, never remembering the answers. He would grow confused. Two years ago, on a trip to San Jose with their kids, now ages 6 and 12, he drove 60 miles in the wrong direction from their hotel, insisting the whole time he knew where he was going.

Maybe his memory loss was the result of depression over two job losses, most recently in 2009, doctors told the Sacramento couple. Maybe it was stress.

He was growing silent and distant, increasingly lost in his own world.

“I’d see him sitting in front of the TV at home,” said Claire Schooley, 45, a network engineer. “He’d say he was taking a break, but he’d forgotten what he was doing or what room he was in.

“He never was like this before. We were having a tough time. I knew in my heart there was something wrong.”

Two days before Thanksgiving 2012 – and almost two years after he sought help from his primary care physician – David Schooley finally was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. For people with the degenerative brain disease, delays in diagnosis can exact a steep cost.

Without timely diagnosis, people with Alzheimer’s lose valuable months when medications can most effectively slow their memory loss. The delay in diagnosis robs families of the chance to enjoy their time together and make financial and legal plans for the future.

Alzheimer’s is now the nation’s sixth-leading cause of death, with 5.4 million people affected. Even so, physicians can be slow to identify the disease in the elderly, despite the fact that old age is the greatest risk factor. And doctors can be even more reluctant to diagnose people below the age of 65 who suffer from the rare, early-onset form of the illness.

“Honestly, it’s a routine thing that families in general try to get the person seen by a knowledgeable physician for more than a year, even a couple of years,” said neurologist Dr. Charles DeCarli, director of the UC Davis Alzheimer’s Disease Center.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that only 4 percent of Americans with the disease are younger than 65. But with the aging of the baby boom generation — and the coming Alzheimer’s epidemic, projected at 14 million cases by 2050 — the hard numbers behind that younger-onset percentage continue to rise.

Typically, experts say, families end up frustrated in seeking help, because primary care physicians aren’t looking for dementia in people still in the prime of life.

 

"Many providers find it hard to believe that someone so young could have dementia or Alzheimer’s,” said Elizabeth Edgerly, the Alzheimer’s Association of Northern California’s chief program officer.

“It’s really difficult. People in their 50s are misdiagnosed with bipolar disorder or depression or even midlife crisis. Or they’re told, ‘Of course, you have memory problems. Who doesn’t?’”

When Bev O’Neil noticed that her friend and employer, Karen Cozakas, was asking the same questions over and over, she thought the memory loss might be related to menopause.

“We didn’t know,” Ms. O’Neil said.

Claire Schooley works from home in Sacramento as she helps her husband, David, balance life between Alzheimer's disease and caring for their two children, Nathaniel and Hannah.
Claire Schooley works from home in Sacramento as she helps her husband, David, balance life between Alzheimer's disease and caring for their two children, Nathaniel and Hannah.

Ms. Cozakas, now 60, a former technology executive who lives outside Placerville, was a competent, upbeat, and organized woman. Then the bank began calling to report bounced checks: It turned out, she could no longer balance her checkbook.

“It seemed everything was going fine, and all of a sudden, everything seemed to shift,” Ms. Cozakas said. “It came on me so fast. Well, to me, it seemed fast. It seemed funny. I forgot little things here and there, but the little things got bigger and bigger.

“And all of a sudden, we were in a bigger place.”

Doctors diagnosed her, at age 56, with mild cognitive impairment — memory loss that in an estimated one-quarter of patients leads to Alzheimer’s — but prescribed none of the drugs that can delay the progression of forgetfulness.

A few months later, she was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s. Now she’s on two medications and participates in a clinical trial through the UC Davis Alzheimer’s Disease Center. And Ms. O’Neil, her longtime friend, is her caregiver.

“We’re better off knowing than not,” said her husband, Michael Cozakas, 61. “You need to know and react accordingly.”

For many patients, diagnosis is delayed because a comprehensive assessment of dementia requires a detailed clinical history and neurological exam, Dr. DeCarli said. The process takes an hour, and most primary care physicians, who can see up to 40 patients a day in their practices, don’t have the time.

“It’s a challenge for primary care physicians,” he said. “I tend to see them adapting a number of strategies. When someone has memory complaints, they get a brain scan and get the patient on memory-enhancing drugs."

Complicating the picture is the fact that dementia has other causes beyond Alzheimer’s: Pain medications, vitamin B12 deficiency, thyroid conditions, chemotherapy, and some infections also can cause memory loss. So can diabetes and vascular problems.

The average person with dementia comes into contact with the health care system four times more frequently than patients without dementia, Dr. DeCarli said.

Beyond the health consequences and frustration, families of patients with early onset Alzheimer’s also deal with the fact that delayed diagnosis forestalls the process of applying for Social Security disability payments.

And, said the Alzheimer’s Association’s Ms. Edgerly: “The travesty of not getting diagnosed is that people are alone. They’re alone, and they have no idea what’s going on. It’s very sad.”

After long delays finally gave way to a referral to a neurologist, Mrs. Schooley hoped for a diagnosis for her husband. By that time, she suspected he might have Alzheimer’s.

But she wanted to know. For him, for their children, for their future, she wanted to be able to plan.

“The neurologist went over the test results and said, ‘You can come back in a year,’” Mrs. Schooley said. “I was really scared it was Alzheimer’s, but after the referral, I thought they’d help us.

“I started crying. I was really upset. I said, ‘I’m telling you, there’s something wrong with him.’”

She insisted on a follow-up test, a scan, which showed decreased brain cell activity.

Her husband of 13 years — the former telecom technician who once could fix anything — definitely had Alzheimer’s. The news came as both a shock and a relief.