Judge rejects consumers' bid to block American-US Airways merger

12/6/2013

NEW YORK -- A federal judge on Friday rejected a last-ditch effort by consumers and travel agents to stop American Airlines and US Airways from merging next week, a move they fear would drive prices up and service down and make planes more crowded.

The combination of American's parent AMR Corp and US Airways Group Inc would create the world's largest carrier and would follow last month's resolution of antitrust objections by the U.S. Department of Justice.

That settlement requires the airlines to shed some landing slots and gates at several airports, including in New York and Washington, D.C., and had won approval on Nov. 27 from U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Sean Lane, who oversees AMR's Chapter 11 case.

AMR has said it hoped to complete the merger on Dec. 9.

In their appeal in the U.S. District Court in Manhattan, plaintiffs led by California resident Carolyn Fjord urged that Lane's order be put on hold, saying they would face irreparable harm if the “anticompetitive” merger went forward.

According to a Wednesday court filing, the consumers and travel agents said combining the carriers could result in fewer flights and available seats, higher fares, poorer service and lower competition, and would be hard to undo once completed.

At a Friday hearing, Chief Judge Loretta Preska of the U.S. District Court in Manhattan said the plaintiffs had failed to shown irreparable harm.

“I adopt Judge Lane's rendition of the law in all respects," she said.

Joseph Alioto, a lawyer for the consumers and travel agents, indicated at the hearing he would seek an appeal. But Preska denied Alioto's request to suspend the effect of her ruling pending an appeal.