Monday, Jun 27, 2016
One of America's Great Newspapers ~ Toledo, Ohio

Politics

Seneca County courthouse foe Nutter defeated

Incumbents fall in other regional races

  • RegCandsmugs07-jpg
  • CTY-saveseneca02p

    CTY saveseneca02p Seneca County commissioner Ben Nutter listens as preservationists make another plea to save the Seneca County Courthouse in Tiffin, Ohio, Tuesday, November 1, 2011. THE BLADE/DAVE ZAPOTOSKY

    <THE BLADE/DAVE ZAPOTOSKY
    Buy This Image

TIFFIN — Sen­eca County Com­mis­sioner Ben Nut­ter, who led the charge to tear down the county’s 1884 court­house, was thrown out of of­fice by a wide mar­gin Tues­day.

Tif­fin busi­ness­man Fred Zoeller, a Re­pub­li­can, pulled in 58 per­cent of the vote in his first run for of­fice.

Mr. Nut­ter, a Dem­o­crat and a Tif­fin fire­fighter, came un­der scru­tiny when he and fel­low com­mis­sioner Jeff Wag­ner voted to de­mol­ish the his­toric court­house at a cost of nearly $400,000.

“I would hope that Com­mis­sioner Nut­ter didn't lose this race strictly as a re­sult of the court­house, but more from the lack of mak­ing de­ci­sions. I call it kick­ing the can down the road,” Mr. Zoeller said. “I'm just over­whelmed with the vot­ers' con­fi­dence in me. I want to com­mend Ben Nut­ter. We kept ev­ery­thing above board. We just have some dif­fer­ent views. I know that I'm go­ing to have to make some tough de­ci­sions, but they will be made in the best in­ter­est of the peo­ple. ”

Mr. Nut­ter did not re­turn calls seek­ing com­ment.

Mr. Zoeller, owner and chief ex­ec­u­tive of­fi­cer of Lam­i­nate Tech­nol­o­gies in Tif­fin, said his fo­cus will be eco­nomic de­vel­op­ment.

Sen­eca County vot­ers also chose Re­pub­li­can Holly Stacy over in­de­pen­dent Paul Shoe­maker to re­place two-term Com­mis­sioner Dave Sauber.

Mr. Sauber, who had cast the lone vote against de­mol­ish­ing the court­house, was de­feated in the GOP pri­mary.

In Wood County, vot­ers chose Dem­o­crat Joel Kuhl­man to re­tain the com­mis­sioner’s seat filled for more than two de­cades by Dem­o­crat Alvie Perkins. Mr. Kuhl­man, a Bowl­ing Green law­yer ap­pointed af­ter Mr. Perkins re­tired, de­feated Re­pub­li­can Doris Her­ring­shaw.

In­cum­bent Wood County Com­mis­sioner Jim Carter, 73, de­feated Dem­o­crat Fred Keith, Jr., and Lib­er­tar­ian Brad Waltz to win a fifth term.

Wood County Re­corder Julie Baum­gard­ner, a Dem­o­crat, won a sec­ond term by de­feat­ing Re­pub­li­can Brian Boos.

In Henry County, two in­cum­bent of­fice­hold­ers were tossed out.

Com­mis­sioner Rich­ard My­ers, a Dem­o­crat who six weeks ago was in­dicted for hav­ing an un­law­ful in­ter­est in a con­tract, was soundly de­feated by Re­pub­li­can Glenn Miller.

Long­time Sher­iff John Nye lost to in­de­pen­dent Mike Bo­den­bender, who re­signed as ser­geant to run for his boss’ job.

Henry County Trea­surer Calvin Spiess, a Dem­o­crat, was re-elected over Re­pub­li­can Zachary Ri­ley.

In San­dusky County, four-term Com­mis­sioner Terry Thatcher, a Re­pub­li­can, re­ceived a fifth term, de­feat­ing Dem­o­crat Glenn R. Baker. San­dusky County vot­ers also re-elected Pros­e­cu­tor Tom Stier­walt, a Dem­o­crat, who was chal­lenged by Re­pub­li­can Tim Braun, an as­sis­tant pros­e­cu­tor in Lu­cas County.

San­dusky County vot­ers elected at­tor­ney Mary Eliz­a­beth Fiser as judge of the county court in Wood­ville. She de­feated Beth Tis­ch­ler, an as­sis­tant San­dusky County pros­e­cu­tor.

The judge­ship ini­tially was not in­cluded on the bal­lot but was added af­ter the Ohio Supreme Court struck down the merger of the Wood­ville and Clyde courts.

In Ful­ton County, Re­pub­li­can in­cum­bent Com­mis­sioner Paul Barn­aby won an­other term, eas­ily de­feat­ing in­de­pen­dent Becky Thatcher. Chief Dep­uty Roy Miller was elected sher­iff to re­place Dar­rell Meril­lat, who did not seek re-elec­tion af­ter 28 years in of­fice. Mr. Miller de­feated Wau­seon Po­lice Chief Keith Tor­bet, an in­de­pen­dent.

In Ot­tawa County, Com­mis­sioner Steve Arndt, a Re­pub­li­can, was re-elected over Dem­o­crat John Huff­man, a law­yer from El­more, while in­cum­bent Re­pub­li­can Mark Stahl was de­feated by Dem­o­crat JoEl­len Regal.

Ot­tawa County vot­ers also chose a new cor­o­ner. In­cum­bent Dr. Jer­ome McTague, a Re­pub­li­can, was soundly de­feated by Dr. Dan Ca­di­gan, a Dem­o­crat from Port Clin­ton.

In Put­nam County, in­cum­bent Sher­iff James Beut­ler, a Dem­o­crat, was de­feated by Re­pub­li­can Mi­chael Chan­dler, a re­tired dep­uty. The three-term sher­iff’s bid for re-elec­tion was likely hurt by his ex-wife’s 2009 con­vic­tion for steal­ing $261,000 from her for­mer em­ployer.

Staff writer Jen­ni­fer Fee­han and Blade Cor­re­spon­dent Lisa Swick­ard con­trib­uted to this re­port.

Click to comment

Quis autem vel eum iure reprehenderit qui in ea voluptate velit esse quam nihil molestiae consequatur, vel illum qui dolorem?

Temporibus autem quibusdam et aut officiis debitis aut rerum necessitatibus saepe eveniet.

Copyright © 2015 Toledo Blade

To Top

Fetching stories…