GIVEN the bizarre circumstances in the Michael Jackson sex abuse trial in Santa Maria, Calif., not many Americans expected the much-tarnished King of Pop to skate free of all 10 charges against him. But he did.
The conventional wisdom was that after a weak start, the prosecution managed to close strong. District Attorney Tom Sneddon s team played a police videotape of the then 13-year-old boy explaining to cops how Mr. Jackson allegedly fondled him. Court observers cautiously predicted a conviction.
Even those sympathetic to Mr. Jackson thought the boy s closing testimony was the silver bullet that DA Sneddon needed. But Michael Jackson s defense team, led by Tom Mesereau, kept the focus on the shakiness of the prosecution s case and the opportunism of a family that seemed out to exploit a vulnerable star.
The jury chose to believe Mr. Mesereau s version of events. As others have noted, it isn t a crime to be weird in America. Still, one doesn t have to believe Mr. Jackson was as innocent as he claimed to agree that the prosecution overreached by loading up its case with a conspiracy charge that was outlandish on its face.
The jurors didn t believe the accuser s mother, the trial s least sympathetic witness, either. Because she gave false testimony in a previous fraud case, her histrionics and lack of credibility undermined the prosecution s argument.
Judge Rodney Melville told the jury to weigh the believability of the pop idol s current accuser only. They took him literally. Given the evidence the jury was working with, they couldn t send Jackson to prison for 20 years on the basis of contradictory testimony from disgruntled employees and a troubled family. They did the right thing in not convicting him.
We agree Mr. Jackson is bizarre by any standard. His insistence that sleeping with pre-teen boys is loving indicates how far removed from reality he is. That doesn t make him a child molester, at least as proven in a court of law, but it isn t a sign of a well balanced adult either.
Michael Jackson should not interpret the verdict as a license to continue the behavior that brought him to the bar of justice in the first place. Though his acquittal was definitive in the eyes of the court, it s the court of public opinion where things will remain dicey for some time to come.
We hope that after a period of introspection, the former King of Pop will confine his affections to his three children, or he will find himself once again in a sad, dark, legal freak show.
Guidelines: Please keep your comments smart and civil. Don't attack other readers personally, and keep your language decent. Comments that violate these standards, or our privacy statement or visitor's agreement, are subject to being removed and commenters are subject to being banned. To post comments, you must be a registered user on toledoblade.com. To find out more, please visit the FAQ.