Tuesday, September 16, 2014
Current Weather
Loading Current Weather....
Published: Saturday, 12/14/2013 - Updated: 9 months ago


‘A Madea Christmas’ is a lump of coal

Anna Maria Horsford, left, and Tyler Perry in a scene from "Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas." Anna Maria Horsford, left, and Tyler Perry in a scene from "Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas."
AP Enlarge

Tyler Perry made his fortune by pandering to a predominantly African-American audience. So a tip of the Santa hat for him trying to broaden his appeal by pandering to a white one with A Madea Christmas, his most integrated movie ever.

Give him respect for making an effort to go against the cultural grain, making a black female character a racist, spouting retrograde sentiments about how all a bully needs is a punch in the mouth, and embracing the “War Against Christmas” meme of conservative news outlets.

But from its unfunny Madea-in-customer-service opening to the abrupt thud of a finale, on into the seriously stiff outtakes that cover the closing credits, “Christmas” is his worst Madea movie ever.

How bad is this tale of race, “Taking the Christ out of Christmas,” and trouble down on the farm? You can’t wait for Larry the Cable Guy to show up.

Yes, it’s that bad.


Written and directed by Tyler Perry.

A Lionsgate release, playing Cinemark Franklin Park, Levis Commons, and Fallen Timbers.

Rated PG-13 for sexual references, crude humor, and language.

Running time: 1:41

Critic’s Rating: ★

Cast: Tyler Perry, Larry the Cable Guy, Tika Sumpter, Eric Lively, Kathy Najimy, Alicia Witt, Chad Michael Murray

Perry and Larry, two old pros at low comedy, could have done a simple two-character farce, bickering about bigotry, hip hop vs. country music, or what have you, and produced a funnier movie. Their scenes at least have a little spark to them. The rest of the movie — none at all.

Madea is fired from her department store greeter gig thanks to assorted “slap the hell outta you” threats. But Eileen (Anna Maria Horsford), her overbearing colleague, talks her into driving with her on a surprise Christmas visit to Eileen’s school teacher daughter, Lacey (Tika Sumpter).

Lacey’s a black teacher to a class full of white kids in tiny Buck Tussle (not to be confused with Bug Tussle), Ala. It’s a town about to lose its Christmas festival because of lack of funds, until Lacey’s ex-beau Oliver (J.R. Lemon) steps in and finds a corporate (and secular) sponsor.

When Eileen, Madea, and Oliver show up, things get complicated. When Connor’s parents (Cable Guy and Kathy Najimy) arrive, there’s almost no room at the inn.

Madea is famous for her malapropisms, mispronounced words in the manner of Mrs. Malaprop, a character from an 18th century play. Mrs. Madea-prop tells Lacey’s students “the story of the Nativitease. The Virgin Mary ... J. Blige ... she went into laborer ...”

The timeline is sloppy, the town “crisis” clumsily handled, and the supporting cast — save for the bawdy Larry and Najimy — couldn’t find a laugh if their lives depended on it.

“The Nativitease,” a couple of mild Madea/​Larry exchanges and this aphorism — “A lie — the longer you let it live, the harder it is to kill” — are all the movie has to recommend it.

That’s not enough to save “Christmas,” a lump of cinematic coal Perry is shoving into America’s stockings this holiday season.

Guidelines: Please keep your comments smart and civil. Don't attack other readers personally, and keep your language decent. If a comment violates these standards or our privacy statement or visitor's agreement, click the "X" in the upper right corner of the comment box to report abuse. To post comments, you must be a Facebook member. To find out more, please visit the FAQ.

Related stories