Thursday, December 04, 2025, 3:51PM | 
MENU
SECTIONS
OTHER
CLASSIFIEDS
CONTACT US / FAQ
Advertisement
Thomas Zich talks with his attorney, Alan Konop, before jury selection for his trial in Lucas County Common Pleas Court.
1
MORE

Trial in 1991 slaying opens

The Blade/Dave Zapotosky

Trial in 1991 slaying opens

Nearly 18 years ago, Mary Jane Zich was found dead in the trunk of her car, abandoned on an East Toledo street miles away from her Genoa home.

She had been missing for several weeks, an assistant prosecutor said yesterday, although it was several days before her husband reported her disappearance to police.

And she had been unhappy in her marriage, so much so that she told others that she was going to get a divorce, Assistant Prosecutor J. Christopher Anderson added.

Advertisement

During opening statements in the murder trial of Thomas Zich, a Lucas County Common Pleas Court jury heard about the months and days preceding the 1991 disappearance of his wife. Mr. Anderson said that through the testimony of more than 25 witnesses, pieces of the puzzle will fall into place, pointing to who strangled Mrs. Zich.

Mr. Zich, of Swanton, was indicted in June, 2007, for murder. He faces life in prison if convicted.

According to his attorney, Alan Konop, many of the facts of the case will be undisputed, namely that the couple had a rocky marriage, that they bought homes together, and that on Dec. 18, 1991, Mrs. Zich was found dead as a result of ligature strangulation.

That s where it all comes down to here, is Tom the one who perpetrated the crime? he questioned.

Advertisement

A jury of six men and six women was impaneled yesterday morning to hear evidence in the trial, which is expected to last two weeks. Four witnesses testified yesterday about the murder case that came to trial after it was reopened by cold case detectives.

Ottawa County Sheriff s Sergeant Jeff Hickman testified that he was called to a Genoa home on Dec. 7, 1991, to take a report of a missing person. Mr. Zich told him then that his wife had not been seen for nearly a week, he testified.

Sergeant Hickman said that throughout his interviews with Mr. Zich, he didn t seem to be that concerned at all.

He wasn t upset, the sergeant said in response to a question on Mr. Zich s demeanor. He wasn t upset at all.

Mr. Konop noted that people in stressful situations react differently, a point to which Sergeant Hickman agreed. The sergeant also acknowledged that prior to Dec. 7, 1991, he had never met Mr. Zich and so did not know how he would react.

Cynthia Beisser, a deputy Lucas County coroner, testified that Mrs. Zich was killed by strangulation, possibly by someone using a rope. She said that because of the cold temperatures at the time, the body had at one time frozen, which eliminated any means to determine the time of death.

Prior to the start of the trial, Judge Gene Zmuda ruled that the victim s daughter, who was 3 years old at the time of her mother s murder, would be allowed to testify. The judge denied the defense argument that because of her young age and the ensuing years of familial influence, the testimony of Desiree Andaverde, now 20, would be unreliable.

Also scheduled to testify are three of Mr. Zich s former wives. The women are expected to testify about experiences of violence with their former husband.

Testimony in the trial will continue today.

First Published June 11, 2009, 1:53 p.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS  
Join the Conversation
Reader comments are now hosted on our social media platforms. We invite you to share your perspective with fellow readers on Facebook and X. You can also make your voice heard by submitting a letter for our opinion pages.
Partners
Advertisement
Victor Singleton signs to Texas A&M with family on Dec. 3 at Central Catholic High School in Toledo.
1
sports
Central Catholic's Singleton, Fryzel excited for next step in careers after signing to top college football programs
Donna and Mark Farnsel, fourth-generation owners of Farnsel Farms, stand beside a digging tractor as their corn lies harvested in Metamora on Nov. 21.
2
opinion
Editorial: Family farm dilemma
William Block, Jr., retired president of The Blade, is donating $1 million to 10 Toledo area nonprofit groups.
3
local
William Block, Jr., donates $1 million to 10 Toledo area nonprofits
Sylvania Township Police Station.
4
local
Former Sylvania Township officer agrees to pay restitution in grand theft charge
Liberty-Benton's Seth Elchert runs with the ball as the Eagles host Delta in a first round OHSAA football playoff matchup on Oct. 31 in Findlay.
5
sports
Toledo football signs MAC's best-ever recruiting class for third consecutive year
Thomas Zich talks with his attorney, Alan Konop, before jury selection for his trial in Lucas County Common Pleas Court.  (The Blade/Dave Zapotosky)  Buy Image
The Blade/Dave Zapotosky
Advertisement
LATEST local
Advertisement
Pittsburgh skyline silhouette
TOP
Email a Story