Tuesday, Apr 24, 2018
One of America's Great Newspapers ~ Toledo, Ohio


Characters go ‘Astray’ in Emma Donoghue’s latest

In her novel Room, Emma Donoghue let us see the world from the van­tage point of a lit­tle boy in an 11-by-11-foot room. In the sto­ries gath­ered in Astray, Donoghue busts loose, re­turn­ing to her roots in his­tor­i­cal fic­tion by go­ing forth into the wider world.

Donoghue’s fel­low trav­el­ers are voy­ag­ers who, be­tween 1639 and 1968, left the world they knew for un­dis­cov­ered coun­tries from which they never re­turned. Each of their sto­ries is in­tro­duced by a date and lo­cale and fol­lowed by a brief snip­pet, rang­ing from a few lines to a few para­graphs, in which Donoghue grounds her flights of fancy in the his­tory in­spir­ing them.

In the ini­tial sec­tion of Astray, each such flight in­volves an es­cape from con­fine­ments which, while less dra­matic than the one in Room, has nar­rowed their pro­tag­o­nists’ choices.

In the first, an el­e­phant and his keeper leave Lon­don’s zoo, bound for new ad­ven­tures in Amer­ica. In an­other, a Jew­ish woman in 18th-cen­tury New York con­fronts her own alien­ation in a cul­ture that doesn’t un­der­stand her.

In Last Sup­per at Brown’s, a slave and his mas­ter’s wife con­tem­plate a new life. In On­ward, a young woman longs for a chance to start over — away from the hyp­o­crit­i­cal world of Vic­to­rian En­gland, in which she was forced into pros­ti­tu­tion af­ter she and her brother were or­phaned.

Each of these sto­ries con­firms Donoghue’s ob­ser­va­tion, in an il­lu­mi­nat­ing af­ter­word, that mi­grants are of­ten strang­ers in the land they leave as well as the one they seek — “strays,” to use her word, who cross le­gal, ra­cial, and sex­ual bound­aries as well as geo­graphic ones.

Men re­al­ize that they love other men. A woman be­comes a cow­boy in un­tamed Ari­zona. Another woman be­comes a ci­gar-chomp­ing pol­i­ti­cian in the Tam­many Hall ma­chine.

Not all of Donoghue’s char­ac­ters can han­dle the free­dom their ad­ven­tures make pos­si­ble. In the mid­dle and fi­nal sec­tions of Astray, men and women try­ing on new iden­ti­ties of­ten re­treat in fear upon see­ing what they find.

In the col­lec­tion’s three best sto­ries, Donoghue’s char­ac­ters per­se­vere, com­ing to ac­cept that their jour­neys into new ter­ri­to­ries of the self will nec­es­sar­ily be par­tial: in­com­plete, lim­ited by how lit­tle any of us can ever see and there­fore nec­es­sar­ily in­clud­ing loss.

In Count­ing the Days, Donoghue draws from sur­viv­ing let­ters of an Ir­ish cou­ple as she jour­neys west from fam­ine-blighted Ire­land to join him in Can­ada; we see all that they share de­spite their many dif­fer­ences — along with the dis­tance keep­ing them apart.

The Gift — com­prised of in­vented let­ters — fea­tures a Jer­sey City mother “whose only crime was pov­erty” and the el­derly Iowa cou­ple who raise her daugh­ter when she her­self can­not. When the mother’s fi­nances im­prove, the Iowans refuse to give the be­loved girl back. Donoghue suc­cess­fully sees things from both sides, forc­ing us to do so as well.

In What Re­mains, which closes the col­lec­tion, an 85-year-old To­ronto woman wres­tles with the grow­ing de­men­tia in her fe­male part­ner of 60 years. A sculp­tor, Florence looks on her be­loved Quee­nie’s face and sees a “blank, like a block of mar­ble that’s never been touched by the chisel.”

But Florence knows there is a “shape locked in­side the mar­ble,” and this beau­ti­ful story helps us see it, giv­ing us a pic­ture of a char­is­matic and vi­brant woman. This col­lec­tion is filled with such acts of imag­i­na­tive sym­pa­thy — each chis­el­ing all that one can, from what Donoghue aptly de­scribes as “the shad­owy mass of all that’s been lost.”

Click to comment

Quis autem vel eum iure reprehenderit qui in ea voluptate velit esse quam nihil molestiae consequatur, vel illum qui dolorem?

Temporibus autem quibusdam et aut officiis debitis aut rerum necessitatibus saepe eveniet.

Copyright © 2018 Toledo Blade

To Top

Fetching stories…