Kyle Newton, 23, was pronounced dead at the scene.
First call came in at approximately 10:45 p.m. Tuesday, and the next about an hour later.
The officer’s name, department was not immediately available.
The man was last seen Wednesday, and family said it’s unlike him not to contact his family.
Kenneth Phillips, 60, faces a fifth-degree felony.
Jakob Kruthaup, 18, is charged with aggravated vehicular assault, failure to comply and grand theft.
Aaron Maddox, 23, was arrested by Toledo police Tuesday and booked in the Lucas County jail.
He may be driving a 2007 red pick-up truck with an Indiana license plate and an eagle sticker in his back window.
News conference marked Mental Health Month.
The driver of the other vehicle attempted to flee after the crash.